When it’s better for a subcontractor to walk away from a federal deal

Victor K • June 15, 2023
A construction worker wearing a hard hat and safety vest is making a funny face.

Things go south when subcontractors are not included in government and contractor negotiations. In the recent past, the US Air Force decided to redo a small construction project. However, the main contractor signed the contract without the consultation of the subcontractor. The actual cost increased, and a dispute was filed with the Armed Services Board of Contract Appeals. Tom Temin spoke with Boone Haynes procurement attorney Dan Ramish for more details on the fiasco.

 

Tom: I think it started when the Air Force changed the ground rules when they decided to do additional work in the form of an alarm system.

 

Dan: I agree. Optimum Construction, a contractor, was awarded a $2 million project to replace a fire alarm system at Eglin Air Force Base. The Air Force changed the contract, shifting the work hours and sequence, which increased costs for Optimum and its subcontractor, Pugh. Optimum initially negotiated with Pugh and the Air Force to capture the changes but faced pressure from the Air Force to agree to a $200,000 modification or risk contract termination. Optimum accepted the modification without consulting Pugh, leading to significantly reduced costs for the subcontractor. The case ended up before the Armed Services Board of Contract Appeals.

 

Tom: Right, Optimum Construction wanted $100, 000 whereas the Air Force agreed to 200, 000 and the subcontractor ended up getting $13,000 instead of the original ask of $100 000.

 

Dan: Yes, Optimum Construction failed to consult with its subcontractor, Pugh, before agreeing to a $200,000 modification. The subcontractor later discovered that the modification did not account for all their costs, as the work was scheduled for nights and required demobilization and remobilization daily, impacting their expenses.

 

Tom: yes, but Optimum paid whatever extra it could to Pugh. What happened next when Pugh wasn't happy with the new deal?

 

Dan: After completing the work, Pugh submitted a Request for Equitable Adjustment (REA) to Optimum Construction for additional costs of $90,000, similar to their original proposal. Optimum, however, expressed surprise and skepticism about the subcontractor's claim. As expected, the Air Force rejected the REA, and when Optimum converted it to a claim, the contracting officer also denied it.

 

Tom: It wasn't over, and an additional dispute was claimed. What did the Armed Services Board of Contract Appeals decide?

 

Dan: The board concluded that there was no additional constructive change as the subcontractor's concerns were already addressed in a previous modification. They emphasized that Pugh proceeded with the work despite raising the issue with the main contractor. The modification included release language, indicating a settlement for the changes. Optimum's claim of signing the modification under duress was dismissed since the government had the right to terminate the contract for convenience.

 

Tom: Right, the dispute now becomes between the main and subcontractor because the government got the job done at the price they wanted.

 

Dan: That’s correct. Main contractors face the challenge of avoiding being caught in the middle when dealing with modifications that affect subcontractors. The main contractor must involve the subcontractor in negotiations to align their interests and secure approval. Failing to obtain subcontractor approval and making disparaging comments can lead to dissatisfaction and potential legal action by the subcontractor against the main.

 

Tom: So in such situations, the subcontractor should just walk away from the table?

 

Dan: Well, if the subcontractor had been involved in the decision-making process and given a choice between a lower $200,000 modification or walking away, they might have made a similar decision. However, since they were not engaged during the modification, the main contractor may now be caught in the middle and incur costs that cannot be recovered from the government.

 

Tom: So what would be your advice to the main contractor if they were your client?

 

Dan: When dealing with a bilateral modification, it is essential to carefully review and understand its coverage. It may be challenging or even impossible to seek additional compensation for the same work due to the inclusion of a standard release. Therefore, addressing subcontractor costs and schedule upfront is advisable, significantly when the subcontractor raises concerns about inadequate coverage.

 

Tom: so, no assumptions about the modified terms and additional payments?

 

Dan: Absolutely correct. The board concluded that the main contractor said it would take about 800 to 900 thousand dollars to get the work done, which eventually was done in $300,000. The gap in this costing and work cost was the basis of the decision against the subcontractor. Therefore, it is better to know the terms and walk away when you can.

 

Therefore, consultation with an expert is essential before taking up big projects. This rule is religiously followed by United Seattle, so there are next to zero disputes, and suppliers or further subcontractors are not dealt a bad hand.

By Victor K March 3, 2026
It is not uncommon knowledge that our generation is paying the most in energy bills as compared to the past generations. Therefore, once a homeowner plans a remodel in Seattle, talking about energy cost savings is a must-have conversation with your commercial subcontractor Seattle. Special emphasis has to be given to the home environment in Seattle due to the humid and rainy conditions all year round. Upgrades that reduce monthly cost provide dual benefits: a reduction in energy bills and an increase in home value. Today, we talk about some major upgrades you should think about while planning for a home remodel. Why Utility Cost Matters Most homeowners miscalculate the amount they are paying extra because of non-energy-efficient homes. The cost trickles down to maintenance cost since HVAC systems are run on overdrive to keep the home warm or cold. The monthly cost + additional maintenance cost becomes a good yearly chunk of your balance sheet. The utility cost is not the only thing that gets battered if energy upgrades are not installed. The value of the home also takes a beating since modern homeowners require these additions as a basic and not just nice to have options. Upgrades that Help Save Energy Cost Experts at United Seattle research and list down their top energy upgrades that not only help reduce monthly costs but also increases home value in the future. Insulation Is Key Insulation holds the key to keeping your home warm/cold without driving up the cost of energy. A trusted commercial construction subcontractor Seattle, like United Seattle , offers insulation services that make your home more energy-efficient and protected against extreme temperatures throughout the year. Options for residential and commercial property insulation include installing fiberglass or using spray foam or cellulose in dry walls , roofs , floors, and even attics, to prevent the heat from escaping. Building subcontractor Washington frequently uses insulation techniques to reduce energy costs later on. Modern HVAC Systems This is by far the best by-product of green living in Seattle. Not only does the carbon emission reduction make the city healthier to live but it also reduces the energy bill, which makes more and more people want to get a modern HVAC system. Commercial subcontractors Seattle is incorporating methods like smart lighting systems, energy-efficient HVAC systems in homes to reduce energy prices, increase home value and provide a better living to Seattle dwellers. Smart Technology Integration The modern day and age has allowed the infusion of technology in the home due to its sheer price reduction and availability. Remote-controlled curtains and automated appliances can add to the overall experience of the home, making it an elegant place to live as well as host an array of people. One can also consider voice-activated systems to control appliances, creating a seamless and futuristic living experience. Apart from the aesthetic benefits, one can use smart thermostats to control the use of energy based on temperature and human presence. This not only reduces monthly bills but also adds value to the home. 
By Victor K February 25, 2026
2026 is one of the most important years in the lives of Seattle dwellers. This is the moment when the debate over moving vs renovating has heated up amid skyrocketing prices for new properties. A simple move decision has turned into a serious financial decision that needs careful thought! All the noise can be diluted down to two numbers: payment math and timeline. The numbers are the only thing you should calculate before deciding on a partial renovation, full-blown add-on, or just getting a new property. A Complicated Decision!! The decision to move has become even harder in the last 5 years than in years gone by. Today, many Seattle homeowners are sitting on mortgages between two and four per cent. That low-rate loan is an asset. Giving it up means replacing cheap money with expensive money. Therefore, a similarly priced home (albeit new) may cost you more due to the 2026 interest rate jump. The interest rate and enhanced payments alone are pushing many homeowners into the remodeling stream rather than the moving one. Understanding Renovation Financing Understanding the financial aspects of the remodel and getting a new home are usually complex processes. The common person is not used to such calculations and may take a rash decision based on vibe rather than math alone. A cash-out refinance replaces your entire mortgage, which rarely makes sense if you’re sitting on a three per cent rate. Construction loans are typically used for large additions or structural transformations. Layered financing is the buzzword as it is better than replacing the original loan. Monthly Payment Puzzle! Your monthly mortgage can jump from $1900 to over $5000 if you take out a $900,000 mortgage for a home that costs over 1 million dollars. This is not just an increase in the monthly payment; everything on your financial balance sheet changes. From the opposite point of view, you take a $250,000 loan for a major upgrade using a home equity loan (HELOC. Even with the current interest rate, it comes down to $2000 a month, which adds to your original monthly payment, keeping the total under $4000. For many Seattle homeowners, that gap is the deciding factor. The Hidden Cost of Moving In Seattle The math above does not include the hidden cost of moving homes and neighborhoods in Seattle. The cost of physical moving, including movers' fees and freight charges, is often under-calculated. In addition, there is a real estate commission that you have to pay as a percentage of the value of both your home sale and purchase. On the buying side, you’ll face lender fees, appraisal charges, escrow, and title costs. Then there’s staging, pre-sale repairs, landscaping refreshes, and actual moving expenses. For a home that costs around a million dollars, the average fee calculated by United Seattle's experts is about $100,000. This is just the cost of moving and has no bearing on your new home design or output. When you include these hidden costs in your five-year financial comparison, remodeling often looks like a very convenient option. Moving Wins Still, but WHEN?? Yes, remodeling is a better option keeping the math in mind. However, it usually disregards the emotional part of the decision. If you are done with the current neighborhood vibe or constantly spending money on home maintenance, then a move to a better home and neighborhood is a wiser decision. The daily commute distance to the school or office also plays a major role, as the cost of it over the next five years should be factored in when weighing an expensive move against a cheaper renovation. Moreover, moving to a smaller property also makes sense if your family members are moving out, as maintaining a large backyard is an annual nuisance. Decision Based On The Future! Always!! Just as with investing in stocks, investing in a renovation or a new home should be kept with the future in mind. Therefore, all math should be done using a 5-year and 10-year model. A home remodel may look cheap now, but added maintenance over the years in an old home can be more expensive than moving into a new home with fewer maintenance costs. The cheaper monthly option is not always the better long-term option, but in Seattle’s 2026 rate environment, remodeling often preserves greater financial flexibility. Cheaper to Add or Buy Big? ADU and DADU in Seattle are among the hottest asks in the industrial market. This is because it instantly adds fiscal value to your property, whether for renting, hosting long-term guests, or creating a workspace. Once you add an addition , you only pay for the renovation (if not financed), and the original mortgage stays intact. This can be a major savings and fiscal addition point over the next decade and must be factored into the decision matrix when choosing between remodeling, an addition, or moving altogether. Timelines Somehow Matter! Oh, the eternal question: how long will the remodel take? If you have to temporarily move out of your home into a hotel or rental, the cost is added to the original renovation cost. This is where a skilled home remodeling company like United Seattle comes in, leveraging its experience to complete the project within the stipulated time and budget. Delays are one of the most common aspects of any remodeling project, which leads to financial loss as well as mental trauma. In principle, remodeling is slower than moving into a new house, but the customization is as per your plan and family needs, which is a big plus! If you can wait out the remodeling process, remodeling is better and cheaper than moving in the long run! 
By Victor K February 18, 2026
Any commercial subcontractor Seattle will tell you that the Seattle construction market is shifting from the vintage model to the new age commercial project management Seattle. Therefore, if you are looking for an upgrade in 2026 or beyond, you must check out the latest trends people are asking for from their commercial construction subcontractor Seattle. The renovation has moved past aesthetics and into the domain of functionality. Yes, aesthetics is important but so is saving space, making the space look bigger and infusing technology and sustainability in the mix. Seattle homeowners are planning improvements that future-proof their properties while staying true to the Pacific Northwest lifestyle. Here are the key trends to watch before starting your next project. Minimalistic Approach Again, a brand-new concept but one that millennials have fallen in love with. Open spaces, less amount of furniture and functional spaces like kitchen and bathroom have made this style very popular in recent years and the trend will move upwards in 2024 as well. This minimalist approach fosters a sense of calm and simplicity in the home. Natural Elements Inside Bringing the outside to the inside is a new approach that many Seattle citizens are coming up with. It generally means having a natural touch inside the house. These elements include the addition of natural lighting, plants and water features that add a new aesthetic angle to the house. Not only do these additions bring value to the home but they also produce a healthier environment to dwell in daily. Sustainability Is King Sustainability is no more a buzzword with most of the contractors providing green services in line with the new laws and regulations. Having a green print of your new renovation will not only bring a pleasant living experience but also reduce living costs, along with increasing property value for the future. Bringing elements inspired by nature, like living walls and eco-friendly wood touches, into indoor spaces will result in homes that align with the city's dedication to taking care of the environment.
More Posts

We Offer All the Services You Need in One Place! We Will Save You Time and Money!

Call Us at (425) 521-7916 Now to Get a Free Estimate or a Free Consultation for Any of Our Services!

Contact Us